mirror of
https://github.com/bevyengine/bevy
synced 2025-01-25 11:25:19 +00:00
379b9e5cb6
# Objective Revert the changes to type parameter bounds introduced in #9046, improves the `#[reflect(where)]` attribute (also from #9046), and adds the ability to opt out of field bounds. This is based on suggestions by @soqb and discussion on [Discord](https://discord.com/channels/691052431525675048/1002362493634629796/1201227833826103427). ## Solution Reverts the changes to type parameter bounds when deriving `Reflect`, introduced in #9046. This was originally done as a means of fixing a recursion issue (#8965). However, as @soqb pointed out, we could achieve the same result by simply making an opt-out attribute instead of messing with the type parameter bounds. This PR has four main changes: 1. Reverts the type parameter bounds from #9046 2. Includes `TypePath` as a default bound for active fields 3. Changes `#reflect(where)]` to be strictly additive 4. Adds `#reflect(no_field_bounds)]` to opt out of field bounds Change 1 means that, like before, type parameters only receive at most the `TypePath` bound (if `#[reflect(type_path = false)]` is not present) and active fields receive the `Reflect` or `FromReflect` bound. And with Change 2, they will also receive `TypePath` (since it's indirectly required by `Typed` to construct `NamedField` and `UnnamedField` instances). Change 3 was made to make room for Change 4. By splitting out the responsibility of `#reflect(where)]`, we can use it with or without `#reflect(no_field_bounds)]` for various use cases. For example, if we hadn't done this, the following would have failed: ```rust // Since we're not using `#reflect(no_field_bounds)]`, // `T::Assoc` is automatically given the required bounds // of `FromReflect + TypePath` #[derive(Reflect)] #[reflect(where T::Assoc: OtherTrait)] struct Foo<T: MyTrait> { value: T::Assoc, } ``` This provides more flexibility to the user while still letting them add or remove most trait bounds. And to solve the original recursion issue, we can do: ```rust #[derive(Reflect)] #[reflect(no_field_bounds)] // <-- Added struct Foo { foo: Vec<Foo> } ``` #### Bounds All in all, we now have four sets of trait bounds: - `Self` gets the bounds `Any + Send + Sync` - Type parameters get the bound `TypePath`. This can be opted out of with `#[reflect(type_path = false)]` - Active fields get the bounds `TypePath` and `FromReflect`/`Reflect` bounds. This can be opted out of with `#reflect(no_field_bounds)]` - Custom bounds can be added with `#[reflect(where)]` --- ## Changelog - Revert some changes #9046 - `#reflect(where)]` is now strictly additive - Added `#reflect(no_field_bounds)]` attribute to opt out of automatic field trait bounds when deriving `Reflect` - Made the `TypePath` requirement on fields when deriving `Reflect` more explicit ## Migration Guide > [!important] > This PR shouldn't be a breaking change relative to the current version of Bevy (v0.12). And since it removes the breaking parts of #9046, that PR also won't need a migration guide. |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| io | ||
| processor | ||
| server | ||
| assets.rs | ||
| event.rs | ||
| folder.rs | ||
| handle.rs | ||
| id.rs | ||
| lib.rs | ||
| loader.rs | ||
| meta.rs | ||
| path.rs | ||
| reflect.rs | ||
| saver.rs | ||
| transformer.rs | ||