25afc9b377 made this unnecessary by
having child processes wait for a signal after fork(), but this change
was later reverted. If we artificially slow down fish (e.g. with a sleep)
after the fork call, we see commands getting backgrounded by mistake.
Put back the tcsetgrp() call.
This runs build_tools/style.fish, which runs clang-format on C++, fish_indent on fish and (new) black on python.
If anything is wrong with the formatting, we should fix the tools, but automated formatting is worth it.
Now that we use an internal process to perform builtin output, simplify the
logic around how it is performed. In particular we no longer have to be
careful about async-safe functions since we do not fork.
Also fix a bunch of comments that no longer apply.
This switches IO redirections after fork() to use the dup2_list_t,
instead of io_chain_t. This results in simpler code with much simpler
error handling.
This switches IO redirections after fork() to use the dup2_list_t,
instead of io_chain_t. This results in simpler code with much simpler
error handling.
This happens in firejail, and it means that we can't use it as an
argument to most pgid-taking functions.
E.g. `wait(0)` means to wait for the _current_ process group,
`tcsetpgrp(0)` doesn't work etc.
So we just stop doing this stuff and hope it works.
Fixes#5295.
* Convert JOB_* enums to scoped enums
* Convert standalone job_is_* functions to member functions
* Convert standalone job_{promote, signal, continue} to member functions
* Convert standolen job_get{,_from_pid} to `job_t` static functions
* Reduce usage of JOB_* enums outside of proc.cpp by using new
`job_t::is_foo()` const helper methods instead.
This patch is only a refactor and should not change any functionality or
behavior (both observed and unobserved).
We've tried numerous approaches to mitigate the race condition between
`posix_spawn` and the `setpgid` call, but unfortunately due to the flags
we pass to `posix_spawn`, it (rarely? never?) results in `vfork()` being
used, which means it is never executed atomically. Since it is executed
out-of-band, we must manually call `setpgid` in case `posix_spawn`
hasn't gotten around to doing that yet, but in the event that it has, an
EACCES error can be returned.
Closes#4884. Closes#4715. See also #4778.
The job control functions were a bit messy, in particular
`set_child_group`'s name would imply that all it does is set the child
group, but in reality it used to set the child group (via `setpgid`),
set the job's pgrp if it hasn't been set, and possibly assign control of
the terminal to the newly-created job.
These have been split into separate functions. Now `set_child_group`
does just (and only) that, `maybe_assign_terminal` might assign the
terminal to the new pgrp, and `on_process_created` is used to set the
job properties the first time an external process is created. This might
also speed things up (but probably not noticeably) as there are no more
repeated calls to `getpgrp()` if JOB_CONTROL is not set.
Additionally, this closes#4715 by no longer unconditionally calling
`setpgid` on all new processes, including those created by `posix_spawn`
which does not need this since the child's pgrep is set at in the
arguments to that API call.
keepalive processes are typically killed by the main shell process.
However if the main shell exits the keepalive may linger. In WSL
keepalives are used more often, and the lingering keepalives are both
leaks and prevent the tests from finishing.
Have keepalives poll for their parent process ID and exit when it
changes, so they can clean themselves up. The polling frequency can be
low.
The process_t pointer sent to setup_child_process can actually be 0
without it being failure, as that is what fish sends when `exec` is run
(in the case of INTERNAL_EXEC).
This was causing exec to fail.
There is no more race condition between parent and child with
regards to setting the process groups. Each child sets it for themselves
and then blocks indefinitely until the parent does what it needs to for
them (having waited for them to set their process groups). They are not
SIGCONT'd until the next process in the chain (if any) starts so that
that process can join their process group and open the pipes.
Setting the process group in a fork/exec scenario is a well-documented
race condition in pretty much any job control mechanism [0] [1]. The
Wikipedia article contradicts the glibc article and suggests that the
best approach is for the parent to wait for the child to become the
process group leader, while the glibc article suggests that both should
make it so (which is what fish did previously). However, I'm running
into cases where tcsetpgrp is causing an EPERM error, which it isn't
documented to do except if the session id for the calling process
differs from that of the target process group (which is never the case
in fish since they are all part of the same session), which should cause
a _different_ error (SIGTTOU to be sent to all members of the calling
process' group).
In all cases, this is easily remedied by checking if the process group
in question is already in control of the terimnal. There's still the
off-chance that in the time between we check that and the time that the
command completes that situation may have changed, but the parent
process is supposed to ignore the result of this call if it errors out.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Process_group
[1]: https://www.gnu.org/software/libc/manual/html_node/Launching-Jobs.html
PR #3691 made most calls to `signal_block()` and `signal_unblock()`
no-ops unless a magic env var is set when fish starts running. It's
been seven months since that change was made and no problems have been
reported. This finishes that work by removing those no-op function calls
and support for the magic env var in our next major release (which won't
happen till at least six months from now).
0 is not a good default PGID, because it's possible for a kernel process
to have the PGID of 0 under Linux.
This meant that job_get_from_pid could return incorrect jobs, as the PGID
for internal, non-forked jobs was the same as kernel processes.
Avoid this by using an invalid PGID as the initial PGID.
