alias: Use read --tokenize

This did some weird unescaping to try to extract the first word.

So we're now more likely to be *correct*, and the alias benchmark is
about 20% *faster*.

Call it a win-win.
This commit is contained in:
Fabian Homborg 2019-11-29 20:09:02 +01:00
parent 86133b0a2b
commit 115892ccd2
3 changed files with 8 additions and 26 deletions

View file

@ -44,22 +44,12 @@ function alias --description 'Creates a function wrapping a command'
return 1 return 1
end end
# Extract the first command from the body. This is supposed to replace all non-escaped (i.e. # Extract the first command from the body.
# preceded by an odd number of `\`) spaces with a newline so it splits on them. See issue #2220 printf '%s\n' $body | read -lt first_word body
# for why the following borderline incomprehensible code exists.
set -l tmp (string replace -ra -- "([^\\\ ])((\\\\\\\)*) " '$1\n' $body)
set first_word (string trim -- $tmp[1])
# If the user does something like `alias x 'foo; bar'` we need to strip the semicolon.
set base_command (string trim -c ';' -- $first_word)
if set -q tmp[2]
set body $tmp[2..-1]
else
set body
end
# Prevent the alias from immediately running into an infinite recursion if # Prevent the alias from immediately running into an infinite recursion if
# $body starts with the same command as $name. # $body starts with the same command as $name.
if test $base_command = $name if test $first_word = $name
if contains $name (builtin --names) if contains $name (builtin --names)
set prefix builtin set prefix builtin
else else

View file

@ -44,22 +44,12 @@ function alias --description 'Creates a function wrapping a command'
return 1 return 1
end end
# Extract the first command from the body. This is supposed to replace all non-escaped (i.e. # Extract the first command from the body.
# preceded by an odd number of `\`) spaces with a newline so it splits on them. See issue #2220 printf '%s\n' $body | read -lt first_word body
# for why the following borderline incomprehensible code exists.
set -l tmp (string replace -ra -- "([^\\\ ])((\\\\\\\)*) " '$1\n' $body)
set first_word (string trim -- $tmp[1])
# If the user does something like `alias x 'foo; bar'` we need to strip the semicolon.
set base_command (string trim -c ';' -- $first_word)
if set -q tmp[2]
set body $tmp[2..-1]
else
set body
end
# Prevent the alias from immediately running into an infinite recursion if # Prevent the alias from immediately running into an infinite recursion if
# $body starts with the same command as $name. # $body starts with the same command as $name.
if test $base_command = $name if test $first_word = $name
if contains $name (builtin --names) if contains $name (builtin --names)
set prefix builtin set prefix builtin
else else

View file

@ -10,9 +10,11 @@ my_alias
alias a-2='echo "hello there"' alias a-2='echo "hello there"'
alias foo '"a b" c d e'
# Bare `alias` should list the aliases we have created and nothing else # Bare `alias` should list the aliases we have created and nothing else
# We have to exclude two aliases because they're an artifact of the unit test # We have to exclude two aliases because they're an artifact of the unit test
# framework and we can't predict the definition. # framework and we can't predict the definition.
alias | grep -Ev '^alias (fish_indent|fish_key_reader) ' alias | grep -Ev '^alias (fish_indent|fish_key_reader) '
# CHECK: alias a-2 'echo "hello there"' # CHECK: alias a-2 'echo "hello there"'
# CHECK: alias foo '"a b" c d e'
# CHECK: alias my_alias 'foo; and echo foo ran' # CHECK: alias my_alias 'foo; and echo foo ran'