No good solution for transitioning the trate name, unfortnately, since
we can't mark `use`s as deprecated (we can, it just does nothing).
I got rid of the `into` prefix because that implies a `self` parameter
that doesn't exist.
Now that we can use `SubcommandRequired |
ArgRequiredElseHelp`, this setting offers little value but requires we
track required subcommands with two different settings. Deprecating as
the cost is not worth the benefit anymore.
Issue #3280 will see the derive updated
Like was said in #2435, this is what people would expect.
While we should note this in a compatibility section in the changelog, I
do not consider this a breaking change since we should be free to adjust
the help output as needed. We are cautious when people might build up
their own content around it (like #3312) but apps should already handle
this with `--help` so this shouldn't be a major change.
We aren't offering a way for people to disable this, assuming people
won't need to. Longer term, we are looking at support "Actions" (#3405)
and expect those to help customize the flags. We'll need something
similar for the `help` subcommand.
Fixes#3440
This is a part of #2717
Some settings didn't get getters because
- They are transient parse settings (e.g. ignore errors)
- They get propagated to args and should be checked there
`is_allow_hyphen_values_set` is a curious case. In some cases, we only
check the app and not an arg. This seems suspicious.
For the derive API, you can only call `next_display_order` when dealing
with a flatten. Until we offer app attributes on arguments, the user can workaround with
this no-op flattens.
This is a part of #1807
This clarifies the intent and prepares for other functions doing the
same, like `next_display_order`. This will then open us to name
`subcommand_help_heading` and `display_order` similar.
The deprecation is waiting on 3.1.
This is part of #1807 and #1553.
This is inspired by cargo which allows you to run `cargo test --test`
and it will list the possible tests (obviously we can't support that atm
because that requires a lot of runtime processing). When we do have a
static list of possible values, we can at least show those.
Fixes#3320
For some errors, we use the unroll logic to get the list of required
arguments. The usage then does the same, but without a matcher. This
was causing the lists to not match.
As a side effect, this fixed an ordering issue where we were putting the
present arg after the not-present arg. I assume its because we ended up
reporting the items twice but the first time is correctly ordered and
gets precedence.
This was split out of #3020
When an Arg uses .min_values(0), that arg's value(s) are effectively
optional. This is conventionaly denoted in help messages by wrapping the
arg's values in square brackets. For example:
--foo[=value]
--bar [value]
This kind of argument can be seen in the wild in many git commands; e.g.
git-status(1).
Signed-off-by: Peter Grayson <pete@jpgrayson.net>
We were only tracking the last value source (default, env, cli, etc).
This works for args because they only come from one source. Groups
however can come from multiple sources and this was making us treat a
group with a default value as being completely from defaults despite
some values maybe being from the commandline.
We now track the highest precedence value for a group.
Fixes#3330
I thought I was adding a test in #3305. Maybe I considered the
clap_complete changes sufficient for this. Doing more `debug_assert`s
would be good also.
Unsetting `PropagateVersion` helps in some cases but we need to unset it
globally to override the global propagation.
Fixes#3310
The error was when doing `#[clap(arg_enum, default_value_t = ...)]`.
Good example of why we should minimize `use`, at least in tests
(besides reducing merge conflicts, code churn, etc).
This reverts commit 333b993481.
PR #1810's motivation was effectively "this is redundant with `\n`".
That is a fine motivation. Unfortunately, we don't have a way to force
a hard break in `clap_derive`. #2389 should help with this eventually
but we shouldn't hold up 3.0 to get that ready. So in the mean time, we
are restoring `{n}`.
We have #3230 for tracking the re-removal of it.
This allows two overriding args to interact with each other mid-line.
This was broken in 7673dfc / #1154. Before that, we duplicated the override
logic in several places.
Now we plug into the start of a new arg which allows us to do this
incrementally without making the logic complex or inefficient, thanks to
prior refactors.
Fixes#3217
While I'm unsure how much type specialization we should do, we
intentionally have the `arg_enum` attribute for doing special behavior
based on it, so let's take advantage of it.
Fixes#3185
The extra whitespace was targeted at machine processing for a subset of
users for a subset of runs of CLIs. On the other hand, there is a lot
of concern over the extra verbose output.
A user can set the help template for man, if desired. They can even do
something (env? feature flag?) to make it only run when doing man
generation. We also have #3174 in the works.
So let's focus on the end-user reading `--help`. People wanting to use
`help2man` have workarounds to do what they need.
Fixes#3096
The main care about is that when we override a `flatten` / `subcommand`
doc comment in a parent container, that we make sure we take nothing
from the child container, rather than implicitly taking one `about` ut
not `long_about`.
To do this, and to play the most safe with long help detection, we reset
`long_about` to default when there is no doc comment body to use for
`long_about`.
Fixes#2983
We have two ways of fixing this
- Making `--help` work
- Don't put `--help` in the help output
For now, I went with the latter. I tried to make it clear what the
actual requirement is so we can pivot if needed.
Fixes#2892
This happens to also fix the interaction of `DisableHelpFlag` with the
help subcommand and complcations. I've added a test to help catch if we
break this by changing how we fixed the original issue.
Fixes#2724
These issues were reported against clap3. I've not tried to reproduce
these in clap2 to see if they should show up in the release notes.
I'm assuming we won't have a negative performance impact by removing
`impl Copy for Id` because the compiler would inline the `clone()`s and
turn them into copies.
Addresses problems from #3164
Adding in a `StructOpt` derive with `structopt` attributes, with
deprecation notices. Unofrtunately, not as many deprecation warnings as
I would like. Apparently, you can't do them for a `use` of a derive? I
also wanted to inject code that would trigger a deprecation notice for
attributes but that would require enough of a refactor that I didn't
consider it worth it. We are at least providing a transition window
even if it means we'll have to remvoe it next major release without a
deprecation warning.
This creates distinct tutorial examples from complex feature examples
(more how-tos). Both sets are getting builder / derive versions (at
least the critical ones).
This is prep for moving the derive tests. Besides organizing the test
folder for each API, this should reduce link time at the cost of
re-compiling more when a test changes.
This both distances itself from our 'require' terminology and aligns
itself with `Option::expect`, making it more likely for people to guess
the intended behavior.
This ports our example testing over to [trycmd](https://docs.rs/) so
we can:
- More thoroughly test our examples
- Provide always-up-to-date example usage
The old way of testing automatically picked up examples. This new way
requires we have a `.md` file that uses the example in some way.
Notes:
- Moved overall example description to the `.md` file
- I added cross-linking between related examples
- `14_groups` had a redundant paragraph (twice talked about "one and
only one"
This is intended to replace the runtime usage parser and is not meant to
be a complete API in of itself, like `clap_app!`. What is in scope is
everything that visually makes sense as in a usage string (see
[docopt](http://docopt.org/) for inspiration). General setting of
attributes is out of scope.
This deviates from both `clap_app` and the runtime usage parser
- `clap_app` supported multiple values but has a bug because we made
`Arg::value_name` non-appending, so we aren't supporting this yet
- We do not yet support optional flags that take a value
- In both, `...` is multiple occurrences and values while its only
multiple occurrences for us
- We explicitly support optional values for flags
- Unlike `clap_app`, our name is optional
- Unlike runtime usage parser, our name syntax is simpler
- Unlike runtime usage parser, our name syntax does not allow modifiers
Its more limited than I would like. Hopefully some people better with
macros can expand the feature set and turn more runtime errors into
compile-time errors.
This is to prepare for deprecating the runtime usage parser (#8).
Since usage parser and yaml are on the way to being deprecated (#8, #9),
doing a rename also seems excessive, so rolling it back.
Past relevant PRs:
- clap-rs/clap#1157
- clap-rs/clap#1257
This reverts commits 24cb8b1..d0abb37 from clap-rs/clap#1840
This is part of #16. clap-rs/clap#1840 wasn't the right call but we
don't have time to make the decision now, so instead of having one
option and changing it in 4.0, this reverts back to clap2 behavior.
This feature is too immature at this stage in the release. See
clap-rs/clap Issue 3020 when bringing this feature back.
This reverts commit 301c6f765a.
This reverts commit 43a4c90c86.
This reverts commit 4e29777b21.
This reverts commit 69957c4ddd.
This reverts commit bdb1d324a5.
This reverts commit b102da0cd2.
This reverts commit 72429be14e.
This reverts commit 0b7def675b.
This reverts commit b86aa631be.
This reverts commit 6b458c602d.
In #2851, we moved color from an AppSetting to function (with some
tweaks in #2907). When doing this, we documented `App::color` to be
equivalent of `App::global_settings(Color...)` but never actually
propagated it.
We are now propagating it. A test is added to ensure that no matter
how we store the color choice, we continue to propagate it. This
required exposing `App::get_color`.
The tests are using `to_string` which maps to `Display::fmt` and the
`Colorizer` version is colorless. To get color, it is only supported
with `print()` which has to go to stdout / stderr and can't be directed
to an arbitrary stream.
Though we store a lot of values as `&'help str`, we return them as
`&'self str`, making it so they can not be used programmatically as part
of a `App::mut_arg` call.
This loosens the lifetimes so they can be used with `App::mut_arg`.
This also includes a test simulating the desired workflow described in #2966
I skipped `get_all_aliases`. I ran into problems with lifetimes with
`all_subcommand_names` and didn't quickly resolve it. Rather than hold
this up, I punted on it for now.
We'll have to tighten these back up with #1041 but that will also enable
turning them into owned strings, so this will still be possible after
that issue is resolved, just the calls will be slightly different.
When supporting multiple occurrences for positional arguments in #2804,
I added some tests to cover this but apparently simpler cases fail
despite those more complicated cases being tested.
This adds more multiple-occurrences tests for positional arguments,
fixes them, and in general equates multiple values with occurrences for
positional arguments as part of #2692. There are a couple more points
for consideration for #2692 for us to decide on once this unblocks them
(usage special case in #2977 and how subcommand help should be handled).
I fully admit I have not fully quantified the impact of all of these
changes and am heavily relying on the quality of our tests to carry this
forward.
In looking at multiple occurrences and values for issues like #2692, I
noticed that `...` can mean both multiple values and multiple
occurrences, like before we split them.
Pros
- No syntax change with clap3
Cons
- All the reasons we split `multiple` into two
Uncertain
- I originally started this as part of another branch but I lost track
if something depended on this. I'll have to do more digging
BREAKING CHANGE: If `--opt [val]...` was meant for
- only multiple occurrences, see `[opt]... --opt [val]`
- both multiple occurrences and values, see `[opt]... --opt [val]...`
In considering potential work for #2683, I realized we might need a type to carry data for
each of the `multiple_values`. `ArgValue` works both for that and for
possible values, so we need to come up with a better name for one or
both. Changing `ArgValue`s name now would be ideal since its new in
clap3 and by renaming it, we can reduce churn for users.
While thinking about this, I realized I regularly get these mixed
up, so renaming `ArgValue` to `PossibleValue` I think will help clear
things up, regardless of #2683.
This gives users the basic error template for quick and dirty messages.
In addition to the lack of customization, they are not given anything to help
them with coloring or for programmayic use (info, source).
This is something I've wanted many times for one-off validation that
can't be expressed with clap's validation or it just wasn't worth
the hoops. The more pressing need is for #2255, I need `clap_derive`
to be able to create error messages and `Error::with_description` seemed
too disjoint from the rest of the clap experience that it seemed like
users would immediately create issues about it showing up.
With this available, I've gone ahead and deprecated
`Error::with_description` (added in 58512f2fc), assuming this will be
sufficient for users needs (or they can use IO Errors as a back door).
I did so according to the pattern in #2718 despite us not being fully
resolved on that approach yet.
2817: Add support for Multicall executables as subcommands with a Multicall setting r=pksunkara a=fishface60
Co-authored-by: Richard Maw <richard.maw@gmail.com>
Who knew people need to ask `help` for how to use `help`?
While auditing `MultpleValues`, I saw commented out code. Looks
its commit (f230cfedc) was part of a large refactor and updating that
part fell through the cracks. Just simply updating it didn't quite get
it to work. The advantage of this approach is it gets us closer to how
clap works on its own.
In clap 2.33.3, `cmd help help` looks like
```
myapp-help
Prints this message or the help of the given subcommand(s)
USAGE:
test-clap help [subcommand]...
ARGS:
<subcommand>... The subcommand whose help message to display
```
But clap3 master looks like:
```
myapp
USAGE:
myapp [SUBCOMMAND]
OPTIONS:
-h, --help Print custom help about text
SUBCOMMANDS:
help Print this message or the help of the given subcommand(s)
subcmd
```
This change improves it to:
```
myapp-help
Print this message or the help of the given subcommand(s)
USAGE:
myapp help [SUBCOMMAND]...
ARGS:
<SUBCOMMAND>... The subcommand whose help message to display
OPTIONS:
-h, --help Print custom help about text
```
We still have global arguments showing up (like `-h`) that will error but its
an improvement! In general, I'd like to find a way to leverage clap's stanard
behavior for implementing this so we don't have to worry about any of these
corner cases in the future.
Note: compared to clap2, I changed `<subcommand>` to `<SUBCOMMAND>` because I
believe the standard convention is for value names to be all caps (e.g.
`clap_derive` has been updated to default to that).
