mirror of
https://github.com/bevyengine/bevy
synced 2024-11-10 07:04:33 +00:00
3c41586154
This commit adds two new `WorldQuery` types: `EntityRefExcept` and `EntityMutExcept`. These types work just like `EntityRef` and `EntityMut`, but they prevent access to a statically-specified list of components. For example, `EntityMutExcept<(AnimationPlayer, Handle<AnimationGraph>)>` provides mutable access to all components except for `AnimationPlayer` and `Handle<AnimationGraph>`. These types are useful when you need to be able to process arbitrary queries while iterating over the results of another `EntityMut` query. The motivating use case is *generalized animation*, which is an upcoming feature that allows animation of any component property, not just rotation, translation, scaling, or morph weights. To implement this, we must change the current `AnyOf<(&mut Transform, &mut MorphWeights)>` to instead be `EntityMutExcept<(AnimationPlayer, Handle<AnimationGraph>)>`. It's possible to use `FilteredEntityMut` in conjunction with a dynamically-generated system instead, but `FilteredEntityMut` isn't optimized for the use case of a large number of allowed components coupled with a small set of disallowed components. No amount of optimization of `FilteredEntityMut` produced acceptable performance on the `many_foxes` benchmark. `Query<EntityMut, Without<AnimationPlayer>>` will not suffice either, as it's legal and idiomatic for an `AnimationTarget` and an `AnimationPlayer` to coexist on the same entity. An alternate proposal was to implement a somewhat-more-general `Except<Q, CL>` feature, where Q is a `WorldQuery` and CL is a `ComponentList`. I wasn't able to implement that proposal in a reasonable way, because of the fact that methods like `EntityMut::get_mut` and `EntityRef::get` are inherent methods instead of methods on `WorldQuery`, and therefore there was no way to delegate methods like `get` and `get_mut` to the inner query in a generic way. Refactoring those methods into a trait would probably be possible. However, I didn't see a use case for a hypothetical `Except` with arbitrary queries: `Query<Except<(&Transform, &Visibility), Visibility>>` would just be a complicated equivalent to `Query<&Transform>`, for instance. So, out of a desire for simplicity, I omitted a generic `Except` mechanism. I've tested the performance of generalized animation on `many_foxes` and found that, with this patch, `animate_targets` has a 7.4% slowdown over `main`. With `FilteredEntityMut` optimized to use `Arc<Access>`, the slowdown is 75.6%, due to contention on the reference count. Without `Arc<Access>`, the slowdown is even worse, over 2x. ## Testing New tests have been added that check that `EntityRefExcept` and `EntityMutExcept` allow and disallow access to components properly and that the query engine can correctly reject conflicting queries involving those types. A Tracy profile of `many_foxes` with 10,000 foxes showing generalized animation using `FilteredEntityMut` (red) vs. main (yellow) is as follows:  A Tracy profile of `many_foxes` with 10,000 foxes showing generalized animation using this `EntityMutExcept` (yellow) vs. main (red) is as follows:  |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| change_detection.rs | ||
| component_hooks.rs | ||
| custom_query_param.rs | ||
| custom_schedule.rs | ||
| dynamic.rs | ||
| ecs_guide.rs | ||
| event.rs | ||
| fixed_timestep.rs | ||
| generic_system.rs | ||
| hierarchy.rs | ||
| iter_combinations.rs | ||
| nondeterministic_system_order.rs | ||
| observer_propagation.rs | ||
| observers.rs | ||
| one_shot_systems.rs | ||
| parallel_query.rs | ||
| removal_detection.rs | ||
| run_conditions.rs | ||
| send_and_receive_events.rs | ||
| startup_system.rs | ||
| system_closure.rs | ||
| system_param.rs | ||
| system_piping.rs | ||
| system_stepping.rs | ||